Mingpu MINGPU LIGHT & SIMPLE

Assessing financial fraud risk: performance pressure, exceptions and oversight

Internal controls · Fraud risk · Financial reporting

Pressure, opportunity and rationalisation offer three ways to examine fraud risk. For boards and finance leaders, their practical value lies in identifying which transactions warrant investigation and who can review them independently.

A board receives a year-end trading update. Sales have just reached the annual target, and receivables have risen sharply in the same month. The finance director explains that major customers usually settle before Lunar New Year. A review can start with three questions. Which orders account for the increase? Who decided to record them in this period? What evidence will be available at the next meeting to test today's explanation?

The fraud triangle groups risk indicators into pressure, opportunity and rationalisation. In this example, a bonus threshold may create pressure. Permission to edit acceptance dates may create opportunity. A team that routinely accepts “the customer will sign eventually” may have learned to rationalise an exception. Considering the three together can focus an investigation. Even a single indicator is worth following back to the facts.

Identify the metric under pressure and the date that matters

Review targets and financing arrangements, then trace the relevant measures across key dates. If bonuses depend on annual revenue, large orders were booked at year-end and goods were returned in January, plot the contract terms, delivery, customer acceptance and returns on one timeline.

Seasonal purchasing can produce a similar pattern. Compare order timing with prior years and check subsequent collections and refunds for unusual transactions. Pressure helps direct the work. The evidence determines what happened on a particular sale.

Financing pressure leaves other clues. Suppose contract bookings and cash both rise as a company prepares to raise funds. Separate customer collections, shareholder loans and financing proceeds, then check when major customers paid. A temporary shareholder advance may improve liquidity but says little about customer demand. Do the operating measures presented to the board make that distinction clear?

Profit targets can also affect expense recognition. Gross margin may improve in a month when the operations lead says external contractors worked overtime to meet delivery dates. Select contracts delivered that month and examine supplier statements, records of services awaiting invoices and payments in the following month. Check whether the costs fell in the correct period, even if the bonus plan applied mainly to sales staff.

Establish who can approve exceptions and change records

A company may require approval from both sales and finance. If one person can amend a delivery date and authorise the corresponding posting, that person can bypass the control. Select manually amended transactions near period-end. Obtain delivery evidence, change logs and approval records from sales and finance, then establish who requested, made and reviewed each change.

A small team may have limited scope to segregate duties. A manager independent of transaction processing can review exception reports regularly, examining each material or recurring adjustment. Retain the source records the reviewer saw and the reason for the decision so the review can be reconstructed later.

Check permissions as they stood on the transaction date. A current user list will miss rights granted and revoked at the previous month-end. Use the transaction timestamp to retrieve access authorisations, values before and after the change, and the final approval. If two roles shared an account, record the resulting limit on identifying the reviewer.

Trace an inventory discrepancy to the control that failed

A warehouse count is ten units short. Possible explanations include a counting error, a transfer in transit, a delayed write-off or misappropriation. Establish the count time and item code, then trace recent receipts, dispatches and transfers. If the warehouse cites an inter-store transfer, obtain the receiving store's posting time and signed receipt. Evidence from the receiving end tests that explanation independently.

If someone entered a write-off after the event, identify who initiated it, the grounds for disposal and whether another person witnessed it. Look for earlier adjustments involving the same staff or storage location. Repeated losses at one location or in one resaleable product can guide the next sample. If several locations show discrepancies in the same direction on the date of a system change, examine data migration first. The pattern guides both the investigation and the remedy.

Examine how management handles a disputed adjustment

“The customer will sign next week” may be a forecast or a justification for recording revenue early. Ask what the customer had received by the closing date and whether the contractual acceptance conditions had been met. If finance raised an objection, check whether the original entry was preserved and whether an authorised person independent of the transaction reviewed the exception.

Boards should examine how a one-off exception becomes routine. Look at recent period-end adjustments. Were promised documents obtained? Were entries reversed as agreed? Did the same person approve similar exceptions again? If sales were booked early for three consecutive quarters on the promise of later acceptance, subsequent payment still leaves the board with a question about the basis for recognition in each original period.

Give the board evidence it can act on

For the year-end orders, the board can request an order-by-order schedule of contract terms, delivery at the reporting date, subsequent acceptance and the movement of cash. Assign someone to obtain independent evidence for each unexplained difference. Report the amount of any confirmed impact separately from the population still under review. The former informs whether the accounts need adjustment. The latter informs decisions on sampling, staffing and reporting deadlines.

When explanations conflict with records, document the inconsistency, preserve vouchers and system logs, and examine other transactions involving the same people, customers or periods. Refer matters involving management to independent members of the governing body. Findings may call for corrected entries, revised permissions or further investigation.

← Back to Mingpu Insights